Decision Is a System

By Chris Whelan, Business Coach & Leadership Mentor based in Wellington, New Zealand

Decision Systems All Comes Back to Me Blog

There is a sentence I hear from business owners all the time:

“Everything still comes through me.”

A customer wants something unusual. Ask the owner.
A team member needs to change a job. Ask the owner.
Someone wants to offer a discount. Ask the owner.
A supplier needs an answer. Ask the owner.
Something has gone wrong on site. Call the owner.

Eventually, the owner becomes the central decision-making system of the business.

And that works. Until it doesn’t.

The problem isn’t how hard you work

Most established business owners aren’t short of work ethic. In fact, that’s often part of the problem.

They’ve spent years learning their business. They know their customers. They understand the numbers. They’ve made thousands of decisions and developed an instinct for what will and won’t work.

So when somebody brings them a problem, they can often solve it quickly.

It becomes easier to say: “I’ll deal with it.” Or: “Just run it past me first.” And, of course: “It’s quicker if I do it myself.”

In the short term, it probably is. But every time that happens, the business learns something.

It learns that the owner is where decisions get made.

Delegating work isn’t enough

Many owners tell me they have delegated. And often they have.

They’ve employed managers. They’ve allocated responsibilities. They’ve handed over customers, projects, administration, operations or sales.

But then you look underneath it and discover something interesting.

The work has been delegated. The decision authority hasn’t.

The manager can run the job – until something changes. They can deal with the customer – until they need to negotiate. They can manage the team – until somebody needs to be held accountable. They can buy something – until it exceeds an unwritten amount.

Then everything travels back up the organisation.

That isn’t really delegation. It is delegated activity with centralised decision-making. And the owner remains the bottleneck.

Decision is a system

This is why I think about decision-making differently.

Decision is a system.

Just like your financial system, sales system or delivery system, there needs to be an architecture behind how decisions are made.

At its simplest, that architecture needs to answer five questions:

  1. What decision needs to be made?
  2. Who owns that decision?
  3. What authority do they have?
  4. What information do they need to make it?
  5. When does it need to be escalated?

If those things aren’t clear, people do what human beings naturally do when they’re uncertain. They ask.

And if the safest person to ask is the owner, the business gradually trains everybody to do exactly that.

Decision rights matter

One of the most useful things an owner can do is make decision rights explicit. Not simply job descriptions. Decision rights.

What can this person actually decide without asking me?

Can your salesperson discount? If so, by how much?

Can your operations manager move labour between jobs? Can they authorise overtime?

Can somebody deal with a customer complaint and spend money fixing it?

Can your manager hire someone? Can they fire someone?

Can they choose a supplier? Can they approve expenditure?

The answer doesn’t have to be unlimited authority. In fact, it shouldn’t be. A well-engineered business has boundaries.

But within those boundaries, people need genuine authority. Otherwise you haven’t really delegated the decision.

Authority and accountability have to travel together

Delegation doesn’t mean abandoning accountability.

If I have the authority to make a decision, I also have to be accountable for the result.

That means knowing what outcome I’m responsible for. It means having access to the right numbers. It means understanding the rules of the game. And it means reviewing performance afterwards.

This is where the Decision System starts connecting with the other six systems of the business.

  • Leadership determines who should own the decision.
  • Operating Rhythm determines when decisions are reviewed.
  • Performance & Numbers provides the information.
  • Delivery determines what happens operationally.
  • Commercial sets many of the economic boundaries.
  • Capacity & Resource determines what people, time and money are available.

The systems aren’t independent. They work together.

Not every decision belongs with the owner

There are decisions that absolutely should remain with the owner, board or senior leadership team: major capital allocation, changes in strategic direction, significant financial commitments, senior appointments, acquisitions, and fundamental changes to the business model.

The objective isn’t to make the owner irrelevant. It is to stop making the owner necessary for decisions that belong somewhere else.

A $50 operational decision shouldn’t require the same decision pathway as a $500,000 strategic investment. Yet in many businesses, both eventually arrive at the same desk.

The test is what happens when you’re not there

One of the best tests of your Decision System is surprisingly simple. Leave.

Not permanently. Take a week away. Then two. Eventually four.

Pay attention to what happens. How many calls do you receive? How many messages? How many decisions wait for your return? How many problems get escalated that somebody else should have been able to solve?

Those interruptions are useful. They’re showing you where the Decision System still depends on you.

Don’t simply answer the question. Ask why the question had to reach you in the first place. Then engineer the system.

From supervision to management

This is part of the transition from a business operating under supervision to a business operating under management.

Supervision says: “Check with me.”

Management says: “You own this outcome. These are the boundaries. These are the numbers. Let me know when we’re outside them.”

That doesn’t mean losing control. Done properly, it gives you more control.

Because control isn’t created by personally touching every decision.

Control isn’t something you exercise. It’s something you engineer.

And when the Decision System works, decisions happen faster, people become more capable, managers actually manage and the owner stops being the routing mechanism for the entire business.

That’s when delegation becomes real. And that’s another step towards building a self-managing business.

A question for this week:

Think about the decisions that reached you during the last five working days. Which of them genuinely required you – and which reached you simply because that’s how your business has learned to operate?

That gap is where I would start.

Decision Systems All Comes Back to Me Blog